| Award | Season | Winner |
|---|---|---|
| Barbarian Trophy | 11 | Jamie Coughlan |
| Lemieux Trophy | 8 | Jamie Coughlan |
| ODBHL Cup | 5 | Jamie Coughlan |
| Lemieux Trophy | 5 | Jamie Coughlan |
| Lemieux Trophy | 3 | Jamie Coughlan |
| Lemieux Trophy | 2 | Jamie Coughlan |
| Lemieux Trophy | 1 | Jamie Coughlan |
| Barbarian Trophy | 1 | Jamie Coughlan |
| ODBHL Tiger Cup | 1 | Dungarvon Stars |